frayadjacent: Close up of late-season Gabrielle in black & white (Xena: Gabrielle)
I briefly considered switching to Final Cut Pro X, so I decided to make an impromptu vidlet with the trial version.

Title: Sparrow's Lullaby
Fandom: Xena: Warrior Princess
Vidder: fray-adjacent
Artist: Amy Ray
Characters: Gabrielle, Xena
Relationships: Xena/Gabrielle
Content Notes: show-typical violence, dissolves. Feel free to contact me with questions about content.

Download | AO3 post | Direct YouTube Link


Working with FCPX was mostly good. I used FCP 7 for my first year or two of vidding, so between that and my more recent experience with Premiere it was easy to use.
  • The import and the clip previews (on the timeline as well as in the window for imported media) were well designed to make it easy to glance at and find out the content of a clip.
  • Editing transitions was easier than in Premiere.
  • Making speed changes was similar to premiere, and easier than FCP 7.
  • It also had a ton of preset effects that I would have made good use of (that short clip of Ephiny's face early in the vid has the 'combat' effect, which I found pretty). I know that I could learn how to do those effects in Premiere, but I am lazy.
  • I had a few issues with the magnetic timeline that probably would have been resolved by watching one or two youtube tutorials (see above RE: lazy). When FCP 7 was discontinued and replaced with FCPX, I was horrified of the magnetic timeline, but it was fine.
  • I disliked the way that clips were organised (by the date they were made!) and couldn't figure out how to change it, but if I were committing to using FCPX I would have googled it and found the workaround that no doubt exists.
In the end I decided that I'm going to stick with Premiere if I can find a way to get my educational discount back (I had it my first year but have subsequently lost it, but I was using an email address from a previous university rather than the one I work for now). The main reason is that I use other Adobe apps, mostly Photoshop (both for work and vidding) as well as Audition and, in principle, After Effects. My partner might also start using Photoshop. Also, I'm wondering if I could ever clip with Media Encoder, if/when MPEG Streamclip goes bust. If I can't get the discount, I will stop my Adobe subscription when it expires in June.

frayadjacent: drawing from hyperbole and a half: cartoon girl at laptop at night, text says "vidding" (!vidding)
Previous years: 2016 | 2015 | 2014 | 2013 | 2012

Vids I made in 2017

Electric Lady (Steven Universe, premiered at VidUKon in June)
Airplane (Xena, September)
Partition (Buffy theVampire Slayer, November)

Favourite

Partition — I enjoy re-watching it, and it’s a different sort of vid, with a different take on Buffy, than I have done in the past.

Least Favourite

Airplane — it’s a fine vid, but it’s my weakest Xena vid IMO. I had a lot of trouble getting something that went with the music like I wanted on the bridge. And I struggled a little with conceptualising it — at first it really was a Gabrielle vs Horses vid, but that was too narrow a concept for an entire vid so it became about the discomforts of travel, but I’m not sure how well the second half connects to the first half.

Most Successful

Partition, I think, in that I saw a few people reccing it. Electric Lady in terms of comments though — I got some really lovely comments on it on DW and at VidUKon.

Most Underappreciated by the Universe

I secretly hoped Electric Lady would take off on youtube because I think it’s better than a lot of the Steven Universe vids I’ve seen out there. (Not all of them of course! Becca’s SU vid, for example, still blows my mind every time I watch it.) Alas, that didn’t happen.

Most Fun to Make

Electric Lady, before my laptop was stolen (see below).

Hardest Vid to Make

Electric Lady, because I was about halfway finished with it when my laptop was stolen. I’d had Premiere installed on my laptop from my previous job, but when I bought my new laptop I couldn’t get it back. I ended up remaking Electric Lady in Lightworks. Now, I’m sure Lightworks is a lovely program, and it’s fantastic that it’s free. But as someone who was just trying to (re) make a vid and wasn’t actually interested in learning new software, it was very frustrating in some ways. It wasn’t just small differences along the lines of those I discovered when I switched from Final Cut Pro 7 to Premiere, but major differences in the workflow that I really struggled with.

Not long after I finished, I decided to splurge on a subscription to Adobe CC even though the cost and subscription program piss me off. I get the educational discount because I work at a university, and I do use Illustrator for work so I can kinda justify it on those grounds. So the work I’d done on Airplane and Partition — both of which I had started in 2015! — was mostly not lost, thanks to my backups.

Also Partition because the process of making it made me so angry at the source that I almost lost all motivation, when it was 90% finished.

The Things I Learned This Year

Back up my vid projects! Keep my laptop upstairs and not where thieves can see them (only helps with middle of the night robberies, but still).

Also, put more effort into vids. Resist the urge to just post it because I’m sick of working on it. It’s the difference between having a vid I rewatch for years to come and almost never rewatching it. This isn’t good advice for perfectionists, but I am definitely not one of those.

Planning for Next Year

My goal is three vids again this year. I managed it last year, which I’m so pleased about because I only made one vid in 2016 and two in 2015. But two of the three vids I made in 2017 (Airplane and Partition) had significant work done on them in previous years. So making three vids again this year is still a step up in productivity.

Also, Xena Warrior Podcast has inspired me to  return to my Xena vid plans, and has also given me courage to go ahead and make one or two of the darker Xena vids I’ve thought about. Not all vids need to appeal to everyone. More than any other fandom, I vid Xena so I can have the kind of vids I want to watch, and sometimes I want to watch a vid that explores the sad and difficult parts of that show.
frayadjacent: peach to blue gradient with the silouette of a conifer tree (vidding!)
I swear, every vid I make I remember halfway through that I don't have to clip everything before I start editing.  And each time it is a goddamn revelation.  This time around, I'd been clipping for months, and I wasn't hating it, but I sure wasn't loving it.  Then I realized, hey, I have a lot of clips here.  I could throw those things on a timeline and have a lot more fun than I am right now.  Maybe even learn a thing or two about my new vidding software while I'm at it.

And it goes both ways -- editing gives me the motivation to keep clipping, but clipping gives me ideas for the vid.  It's a good back and forth.  I lose a little time by editing stuff that I end up replacing later once I discover better clips, but I bet I make that time up just by having more vid farr.  Plus it makes the experience overall more fun, which might have something to do with why I'm doing this in the first place?

So in the last two days I've filled up about 2/3 of the timeline for Sekrit Vid.  It's been a lot of fun!  I've been toying around with it a lot, moving between different parts of the vid, trying stuff out in one section till I get tired of it, tightening edits in another until I'm happy enough with it, for now anyway.  I'm still not sure what exactly I'm going to do with the other third, but hey, that's what clipping is for.  And that's my next task, as I've nearly exhausted the clips I have. 

And I'm doing it all in a spiffy new program -- Premiere Pro CS6, which came with my new laptop that came with my new job.  Mostly it's a lot like FCP 7, but prettier to look at.  I LOVE (really, really, a lot) that I can scrub through a preview of clips with the icon view -- it saves me soooo much time.  There's still a few kinks.  When I double click on a clip in the timeline to open it in the viewer (or whatever Premiere calls the monitor on the left), I keep expecting the viewer playhead to be on the same frame as the sequence playhead was.  I've found this is only the case maybe half the time?  I'm sure there's a reason for the discrepancy, but I don't know it yet.  It sounds like a small thing but it does slow down my fine-editing process -- I guess I need to adjust that part of how I work.  

I checked out Adobe's official "Classroom in a Book" for Premiere, and so I'm also learning some things I aught to know by now -- like what alpha channels and chroma keys are -- and I'm excited to use them.  Eventually.  Same with After Effects and all that.  Fancy titles and whatnot are exciting, but I bet I'll get the most use out of AE's de-noising effects, stuck as I am on shows that started in the 90s.

Profile

frayadjacent: peach to blue gradient with the silouette of a conifer tree (Default)
fray-adjacent

September 2025

S M T W T F S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
2122 2324252627
282930    

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated 4 January 2026 04:04 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios